[Issue] Why the Next Bitcoin Upgrade is Important

Table of Contents

1. Background - Major Upgrades: Segwit, Taproot, and OP_CAT
1.1 SegWit (2017) - Scaling Bitcoin Block space, Birth of Bitcoin Cash
1.2 Taproot (2021) - Improving Bitcoin's Efficiency and Privacy
1.3 OP_CAT (aka. BIP-420) - Foundation for the Growth of Bitcoin Ecosystem
2. Takeaway
2.1 Junhyun from Hashed
2.2 Heechang from Four Pillars - “Next Phase of Digital Gold”
3. Resource

Researcher

Four Pillars

Heechang

JunHyun

Related Projects

Bitcoin

Many believe Bitcoin remains static due to its immutable architecture. With no clear roadmap beyond its halving schedule, predicting Bitcoin's future is challenging. However, Bitcoin can go through upgrades through community consensus. If a majority of full nodes agree, Bitcoin can implement upgrades via soft forks, introducing new functionalities.

This article examines Bitcoin's major past upgrades and explores OP_CAT, the anticipated next significant upgrade. Let’s delve into the significance of these upgrades and explain why they represent crucial milestones in Bitcoin's history.

1. Background - Major Upgrades: Segwit, Taproot, and OP_CAT

1.1 SegWit (2017) - Scaling Bitcoin Block space, Birth of Bitcoin Cash

The SegWit upgrade, implemented in August 2017, was Bitcoin's first major attempt to address scalability issues. Prior to SegWit, Bitcoin blocks stored a combination of signature and transaction data. This approach was inefficient, as the space allocated for signatures was disproportionately large compared to the actual size of the signature data.

Two opposing solutions emerged: one group advocated for increasing Bitcoin's block size, while the other sought to maintain the existing block size but improve efficiency. SegWit, the latter solution, separated signature data from transaction data through a core logic upgrade. It created a separate storage space called the "witness area," allowing more transaction data to be recorded in each Bitcoin block.

As a result of the SegWit upgrade, the amount of transaction data that could be stored in each block increased fourfold. This improvement led to faster transaction processing and reduced fees.

Source: What Is Segregated Witness (SegWit)? | River

1.2 Taproot (2021) - Improving Bitcoin's Efficiency and Privacy

Taproot, implemented in November 2021, marks another significant Bitcoin upgrade following SegWit. This upgrade enhanced Bitcoin's efficiency and privacy by introducing the Schnorr Signature and Merkle Abstract Syntax Tree (MAST).

Previous to Taproot, Bitcoin's signature method relied on the Elliptic Curve Digital Signature Algorithm (ECDSA), which required one signature per transaction. This approach led to increased signature data size and easier transaction tracking when multiple wallets sent funds to a single address.

Schnorr signatures address ECDSA's limitations by combining multiple signatures into one unique signature. This dramatically reduces the proportion of signature size in a block. Moreover, even transactions with multiple functions appear as a single transaction, bolstering user privacy.

Additionally, the Merkle Abstract Syntax Tree (MAST) allows Taproot to process complex Bitcoin transactions more efficiently. It does this by introducing logic that extracts and verifies only the hash values of required scripts.

Unlike the SegWit upgrade, Taproot was implemented with near-unanimous support from the Bitcoin community.

Source: The Bitcoin Taproot Upgrade Explained | Paxful University

1.3 OP_CAT (aka. BIP-420) - Foundation for the Growth of Bitcoin Ecosystem

OP_CAT is being widely discussed as Bitcoin's next upgrade. It's a simple 13-line code that Satoshi deactivated in 2010 to protect Bitcoin from DDoS attacks. OP_CAT allows the concatenation of multiple elements in the Bitcoin system. Today, there's a push to reintroduce OP_CAT with safeguards against DDoS attacks, such as limiting replication size. This reintroduction, known as BIP-420, could be a significant milestone for Bitcoin's ecosystem, enabling various developments including Layer 2 solutions.

As highlighted in "The Real Way to Scale Bitcoin with L2," Bitcoin's script is stateless. However, combining OP_CAT with Schnorr signatures could allow Bitcoin to enforce specific actions and verify state changes. This is crucial because blockchain fundamentally stores states. If state changes can be confirmed within Bitcoin, it opens the door for internal smart contracts. Furthermore, OP_CAT could enable STARK verification, facilitating Bitcoin deposits and withdrawals through zero-knowledge proofs. Starkware has already demonstrated zero-knowledge proof via STARK on Bitcoin Signet. Many anticipate a soft fork to introduce OP_CAT in the near future, potentially revolutionizing not just the Bitcoin ecosystem, but the entire crypto landscape.

Source: How Op_CAT Plays into the Bitcoin's History | Trust Machines

2. Takeaway

2.1 Junhyun from Hashed

The direction of the next upgrade after Bitcoin will be an upgrade that directly helps expand the Bitcoin ecosystem rather than improving its inefficiency. The meaning of unlocking the potential of Bitcoin is way beyond than just emergence of another ecosystem. Expanding Bitcoin ecosystem will open the way to integrate the fragmented blockchain space into one, taking advantage of synergy with the Ethereum ecosystem. As the clues to the scalability of Bitcoin are unraveled one by one through future upgrades, the Bitcoin ecosystem will inevitably expand. Here, we need to think about what the financial system of the future will look like once more.

2.2 Heechang from Four Pillars - “Next Phase of Digital Gold”

Bitcoin is renowned for its resistance to change, with past disagreements resulting in forks like Bitcoin Cash and Bitcoin SV. The proposed OP_CAT addition, while controversial, promises an impact greater than any previous upgrade.

The introduction of OP_CAT to Bitcoin could enable secure scaling solutions, fostering a robust Bitcoin ecosystem. Its ability to concatenate multiple elements allows for proof verfication including zkRollup deployment. For example, Starkware recently tested a STARK-based zkRollup on the testnet.

Gold's value stems from its scarcity and recognized utility. Similarly, Bitcoin, now firmly established as "digital gold," is entering a new phase where its applications are being explored. With the OP_CAT upgrade, this digital gold could become the foundation for building digital infrastructure and finance.

3. Resource

Related Articles, News, Tweets etc. :

What is OP_CAT?
Starkware -
The path to general computation on Bitcoin

The author of this report may have personal holdings or financial interests in assets or tokens discussed herein. However, the author affirms that no transactions have conducted using material non-public information obtained in the course of research or drafting. This report is intended solely for general information purposes and does not constitute legal, business, investment, or tax advice. It should not be used as a basis for making any investment decisions or as guidance for accounting, legal, or tax matters. Any references to specific assets or securities are made for informational purposes only and should not be construed as an offer, solicitation, or recommendation to invest. The opinions expressed herein are those of the author and may not reflect the views of any affiliated institutions, organizations, or individuals. The opinions and analyses expressed herein are subject to change without prior notice. In addition, beyond the individual disclosures included in each report, Four Pillars, may hold existing or prospective investments in some of the assets or protocols discussed herein. Furthermore, FP Validated, a division of Four Pillars, may already be operating as a node in certain networks or protocols discussed herein or may do so in the future. Please see below links in the footer for FP Validated's participating network disclosures and for broader disclosure details.